Aha!

Can I be the hen?
Colored Eggs

While I was trying to recall the actual intricacies to this game, I DID remember one thing: Whenever me and the sibs played this game, we'd pick the most ridiculous colors ever. I mean, I was never the "yellow" egg, I was the "Yellow-Orange" egg. I'd defend myself by saying that that was a real color in the Crayola box. We finally had to make rules regarding color choice. For instance--you had to be a color that was in the SMALL box, not the jumbo, made-up-colors box. "Red" was okay, "Brick" was not. "Brown" okay--"Sepia," not so much.